Gender | Garfield Gender Debate | Know Your Meme

Gender [edit source ] There is an edit war going on currently about Garfield's gender. There's a quote from a Mental Floss piece being used to support none, there's no source cited there for male. It seems to me there are three options: 1. List its gender as none, citing Mental Floss 2. List his gender as male, either citing a source in the infobox or with a source cited elsewhere in the article 3. Omit his gender entirely Option 1 might entail pronoun changes throughout the article. What I would like to see is discussion here about which option is best supported by sources and best complies with WP policy. Edit summaries are not a substitute for talk-page discussion. I would prefer to have the discussion move here naturally, but if I need to enforce it by reverting it to the last version before the edit war started and protecting the article, I'm prepared to do so.-CFred (talk) 15:36, 25 February 2017 (UTC)

Share Pin Download More

gender wikipedia

Origin Entry: Garfield Gender Debate

File type: jpg

Resolution: (838px x 580px)

File size: 77.3 KB

Guys, Garfield is actually a lasagna.

Virgil Texas @virgiltexas "duhhh Garfield's Pet Force is canon." DOES THIS LOOK CANON TO YOU?

Information Species Gender Family Tabby cat Malel 121314] Jon Arbuckle (owner) Sonja (mother) Raoul (brother) Odie (family pet do Spouse(s) Birthday Arlene (girlfriend) June 19, 1978

View All 10 Images

More:

Wikipedia Edits

as male, and always using male pronouns. Here is but a small sample of strips I found after a cursory search on garfield.com 1. Garfield adopts a superhero persona he names "Amoeba Man", using male pronouns and once referring to himself as "fella": https://garfield.com/comicH 983/06/20 ; https://garfield.com/comi 1983/06/21@ ; https://garfield.com/comic 1983/06/23 ; https://ga eld.com/comic 1983/06/24夕; https://gameld.com/comi 1983/06/25 2. Jon refers to Odie and Garfield together as boys: https://gameld.com/comi 1978/11 12 ; https://gar eld.com/comic/1984/12/2s@ ; https://garfield.com/comic/1999/02/22 ; https://garfield.com/com.c/2014/07/27固 3. Jon refers to Garfield singly as a boy or a man: https://gameld.com/comic 1979/04/19逴; https://garfield.com/comic 1979/06/020 ; https://garfield.com/comic 1980/09/149 ; https://garfield.com/comic/1981/10/11 https://garfield.com/comic/2000/11/20 https://garfield.com/comic/2011/11/27& 4. Jon refers to Garfield (disguised as a human) as his son: https://garfield.com/comic/1 980/10/01 5. Garfield plainly refers to himself as a "boy cat" and a "bachelor": https://garfield.com/comic/1 979/08/20 6. Garfield refers to himself as a "bad boy": https://garfield.com/com.c/1981/07/28 7 Garfield refers to himself as a guy": https://garfield.com/comic 1 981/08/12 ; https://gameld.com/comi / 1 981 11 /079 https://gameld.com/comic 1 981 1 2/279 https://gameld.com/comic 1 9991 1 /24 8 Garfield's magical talking bathroom scale probably a proxy for Garfield himself refers to Garfield as a young man and a boy https://ga field.com/comic/2008/01 17 9. A cat brushes off Garfield's advances and calls him, generically, "Jack": https://garfield.com/comic/1 981/02/15 10. Garfield refers to himself as a renaissance man, and another cat refers to him as both a man and a boy: https://garfield .com/comic/1984/11/04 11. A cat refers to Garfield as "guy", and Garfield refers to his own "manly pose": https://garfield .com/comic/1984/12/08囫 12. Arlene refers to Garfield as "fella": https://garfield.com/comic/1981/10/08 13. Arlene implies Garfield's gender identity differs from her own, which is identified in the strip as "girl": https://garfield.com/comic/1983/05/25 14, Garfield thinks to himself he'd "make a lousy father": https://garfield.com/comic/1 983/06/05 15. Garfield refers to himself as a "kind of guy": https://garfield.com/comic/1984/05/15 16. Arlene refers to Garfield as a "him": https://garfield.com/com.c/1984/10/24固 17. In a Sunday title/precomic, Jim Davis has Garfield roleplay a prince, not a princess: https://garfield.com/comicH 988/07/24 18. In a Sunday title/precomic, Jim Davis has Garfield roleplay a scoundrel that self-identifies as a "him": https://garfield.com/comic/1 988/10/23 19, Garfield refers to himself as a "regular guy": https://garfield.com/comic/1 993/02/23 DrCliche (talk) 07:14, 26 February 2017 (UTC)

Pin

Know Your Meme

Like Page 1.8M likes